Skip to main content

My Choice.



“My Choice………..”



                       
               Now  a days, we find the controversy of Deepika Padukone’s  vogue video  "My Choice” . Because it is said that it is based on women empowerment but the reaction of audience are totally different.  I don’t know where is the problem in film? And why people suddenly criticized Deepika Padukone more than its director – Homi Adajani?

                                     According to me , there is no any kind of controversy of video but.. “The Title” suggest something which is not actually new but it is not digested by society. After reading the article of  My “Choice” by Kajal Oza Vaidya   in ‘Madhurima’,  I get some new point for that. Our rigid and orthodox society never accept the freedom of women even in 21st  century.

         They have no any problem with video if there is no any single word represent’s women selection and any choices or free will. But when Deepika utters the words  " Its My Choice”  - it seems like atom bomb to them which is blasted everywhere.

                                    There is the problem with the word “ My” is more important than the “ Choice” because  being a women , they have no right to decide something not something but everything. Women have no right to take quick decisions and our man stream society never allow to them their freedom and never ever want to free them from the bondage and so called rituals, also.   

                         Even in their dream, they can’t think that women have equal rights and has their own life ,also. She needs someone’s support through out her life and follow his rules.  She has to live according to Father, Brother, Husband, Son, etc… and all these things happens with the name of emotions feelings and love or the name of caring…means she can’t live life as she want. She can’t do work which she want.

                        Feminist and anti- feminist both are there. I think words “ My” and “Choice” both are very opposite for women. Because in our society , there is no insight to see women as human beings. Woman  may be someone’s daughter, sister, friend, wife , she has many role but never see her as a person…..

              Being a girl , one must have to learn accept all things from the childhood. She has no selections or any choices or any options. She must accept all those things as it is. She can’t do any changes and can’t raise her voice against the whole. If she raises the voice against it , she is judged as the bad , “ Asanskari”, doesn’t has any sense and so many things…

                        All that things happens from the beginning , so there is no much surprised but sometimes it is too much suffering and painful for her. about it … Because from the beginning of earth women  are treated as inferior. Adam also treats Eve as inferior.     
      
             No, doubt, we talk about equality, educations and intelligences and so many things but when the time comes to prove , we quit. Because there is fear that …if she gets all things , what will we do ? they know that women have tremendous power  to do anything.
                       
                         Draupadi – is the best example of it. Because she has no any selection or choice after  mother Kunti’s  blessing or cruse which you want to say. and then she must live her whole life among five husbands. 

                         Just imagine that………….

“ If the words “ My Choice” is spoken by actor rather than actress , the same controversy is there?”
                       
             I think  No, because Men are always privilege over women. In our male dominance society , male always superior . They just want to take proud that they give something to women. like…… Opportunity, space , freedom ,  all those things which she want. It is given by them to her not taken from herself. Means….  She can’t select or choose something for herself.

                         We can’t live with so narrow thinking . we just show off that we are modern of 21st century and still our minds are thinking like we are in 18th century. We can’t progress with such thoughts. And I am not fever of women or I am not feminist also. But.. we have to think why only women are responsible for whole?
Why she is blamed every time? Do you not think both are inter-dependent?  Then why just when  women talk about freedom and all those things, our pillars of Culture and Sanskar feel the earthquake??
           
                                                                       

Comments

  1. nicely put arguments, at some level quite true, but it's not always man who wants to dominate women, many times they themselves wants to rule over each other, sometimes a girl wants to live her life as she wants but there is always a woman who denies her!! in more than 80% cases... in matter of boy his father and mother both have control over him, but it's love of mother that allows him to do what he wants.... I'm not blaming anybody but it's fact always man are not responsible for what is happening with her... actually Deepaka is also brought up in the same society in which we are living....... but what make difference is obviously her choice that is not given to her but she has taken it..

    ReplyDelete
  2. In our culture, we find male dominant structure of society. Why so many things are imposed to them? At surface level, we find everything is good & well but it seems like show off. Why educated people also can't accept the freedom of women? I personally believe that both have their respective position in the society, then why one is so supressed? Both have equal right to select their way of life.Then, Why With the name of relationships, Cultures and Sanskar, girls are restricted ? or if she chooses her way she will be criticesd by Society? Struggle is always there for women because male dominant society don't give anything without paying coast. We need to change perspective to see.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Analysis of the Gazal- Chandi jaisa rang hai tera

Chandi jaisa rang hai tera - Lyrics  Chandi jaisa rang hai tera, sone jaise baal Ek tuhi dhanvaan hai gori, baaki sub kangaal Chandi jaisa rang hai tera, sone jaise baal Ek tuhi dhanvaan hai gori, baaki sub kangaal Ek tuhi dhanvaan hai gori, baaki sub kangaal........ Jis reste se tu gujre, voh phoolon se bhar jaye Jis reste se tu gujre, voh phoolon se bhar jaye Tere pair ki komal aahat sote bhaag jagaye Jo patthar choo le gori tu voh heera ban jaye Tu jisko mil jaye voh, tu jisko mil jayeVo ho jaye malamal Ek tuhi dhanvaan hai gori, baaki sub kangaal Chandi jaisa rang hai tera sone jaise baal Ek tuhi dhanvaan hai gori, baaki sub kangaal....... Jo be-rang ho us par kya kya rang jamate log Jo be-rang ho us par kya kya rang jamate log Tu naadaan na jane kaise roop churate log Nazaren bhar bhar dekhen tujhko aate jaate log Chail chabeeli rani thoda, Chail chabeeli rani thoda ghoonghat aur nikaal Ek tuhi dhanvaan hai gori, baaki sub kangaal Chandi jaisa rang h...

અખેપાતર

અનુભવોનું અકળ પાત્ર - અખેપાતર Bindu Bhatt is well known Gujarati writer. 'Akhepatar' (1999) have awarded the 'Sahitya Akademi Award' for the 2003. Novel has the  female  protagonist Kanchanba.  આમ તો આખીયે વાત કાંચનબા ના જીવન ની જ છે ને તેમ છતાંય એમાં ઘણું છે જે એક સ્ત્રી ને જ નહીં આખાય માનવજગત ને લાગું પડે છે.  Chandrakant Topiwala said that...... "સામાજીક ચેતનાની આધારભુત ભારત ના ભગલાંના વિષયની છે ને તેમછતા ભારતના વિભાજન કરતા એ વિભાજન ને કારણે પાત્રોની બદલાતી આવતી નિયતિ નિરૂપનનો વિષય છે."  કંચનબા ની પીડા,દુઃખો ને વેદના ને   ભુતકાળ માંથી એ વર્તમાન ને  નવો અર્થ આપે છે. This is story of journey not only from Outside but the most necessary from the 'inside' also. નવલકથા માં કંચન થી લઇને કાંચનબા સુધી ની સફર છે. After the partion of IIndia & Pakistan, People are suffering from agony. They  hate their own disgustful life. Many people lost their family members and family is broken down. And Kanchnba is one of...

માધવ ક્યાંય નથી !

માધવ ક્યાંય નથી .......                                  -    હરિન્દ્ર દવે          ‘Madhav  Kyay nathi’  is written by very renowned writer Harindra Dave. The title of the novel – itself suggest something. I think there are two aspect of the title. First , he is not at any particular place means that he is omniscient . And second meaning is that he is no where!               The plot of the novel also deals with this idea and gradually reveals the whole events of Krishna’s life. The story  of the novel reveals not only Krishna’s journey from his birth but also with him we find the journey of Naradmuni who wants to meet Krishna but unfortunately he can’t.                 The novel based on only Naradmuni’s desire or extreme eagerness to meet Krishn...